For this Journal, you are required to select a news article about civil liberties. It must be at least 4 paragraphs in length and come from a major, national news source. The article you select will determine your success.
Civil Liberties
News Journal Written Assignment:
For this Journal, you are required to select a news article about civil liberties. It must be at least 4 paragraphs in length and come from a major, national news source. The article you select will determine your success.
For a list of sources and search possibilities, please go to the Media tab, on the POS 2041 Lib page. You may also use the Internet (i.e. Google) to find a relevant article for this assignment. After reading the article and the chapter about civil liberties, address each of the elements below.
-
- Summary – Summarize in paragraph form the facts and issues presented in the article. Document the source of your information with a parenthetical reference, i.e. (Sanger and Broad 2019, para. 4).
- Application – Apply three or more concepts from the assigned chapter to the main ideas in the news article. Specifically explain how the material in your textbook is illustrated in the article you are examining. This can be accomplished by using examples from the article and terms or concepts found in the textbook. You must clearly define the concepts and provide in-text citations in the APA format, including the page numbers, i.e. (Krutz 2019, p. 15) for our textbook.
- Analysis – Conclude with an analysis and reflection of the issue that includes reasoning related to concepts within POS 2041 an analysis of the article perspective. Does the article present the issue in a way that influences as well as informs. Lastly, include your own observations of the issue, the actions of those involved or an anticipated outcome related to your understanding of the concepts covered within the course.
- Summary – Summarize in paragraph form the facts and issues presented in the article. Document the source of your information with a parenthetical reference, i.e. (Sanger and Broad 2019, para. 4).
Answer
Civil Liberties
By: Essayicons.com
- Summary
The article addresses the civil liberties dilemmas caused by the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States. Biskupic mentions President Donald Trump’s consideration of state quarantines and how it affects people’s rights. Civil liberties advocates argue that although extreme measures are required in order to manage and control the pandemic, there should be a limit to these measures (Biskupic, 2020, para.1). Similarly, Biskupic states that legal experts emphasize that the measures put in place should be reasonable, applicable to all citizens, and fair (Biskupic, 2020, para. 4).
She discusses the legality of quarantine measures and the extent to which these measures should not interfere with or affect human rights. She further states the various legal challenges that have emerged, including lawsuits regarding the classification of services as essential or non-essential and concerns about the treatment of people in quarantine zones (Biskupic, 2020, para. 6). The article concludes by asking the federal government to balance between protecting public health and conserving civil liberties during the pandemic.
- Application
Three concepts from Chapter 4 relevant to the article’s main ideas include freedom of movement, the right to fairness and equal treatment, and privacy. The news article discusses the controversy surrounding state quarantines and travel restrictions imposed during the COVID-19 pandemic. This relates to the concept of freedom of movement and travel that has been sensibly acknowledged as an essential constitutional right under the Fifth Amendment (Krutz, 2019, p. 116). The article advocates for upholding and preserving this right while addressing health concerns.
The article also discusses the legal experts’ emphasis on the government’s role to impose reasonable, equitable and fair measures. This relates to the textbook’s concept of civil liberties which states that the government is limited to formulate laws and regulations that are fair, equal, and applicable to all, and to uphold all civil rights (Krutz, 2019, p. 102). Lastly, the concept of right to privacy which limits the government’s intrusion into ones private affairs and how the infringement of this right maybe justified (Krutz, 2019, p. 116) relates to the article’s concerns about potential government surveillance and tracking measures.
- Analysis
Since the article explores the balance between civil liberties and health interests, particularly regarding travel restrictions, quarantine measures, and the classification of services, the concepts covered in the course, such as freedom of movement, equity and fairness, and privacy, are critical for analyzing this issue.
The article presents the issue in a way that influences and informs the reader. It offers an overview of the contradictory views of government measures and civil liberties advocates who are against extreme measures. By presenting the various legal challenges, the article encourages readers to consider the implications of civil liberties in times of crisis.
From my observation, it is clear that protecting public health during times of crisis without affecting individual rights is challenging. Nonetheless, the government and policymakers should try to balance the two. The liable bodies must do their best to ensure that civil liberties are upheld, even during times of crisis, and that any measures implemented are justified, temporary, and subject to regular review.