Discussion Topic: What Would You Do?

Instructions

Prompt
After reading Chapter 2 of the textbook, including the “Ring of Gyges” story from Plato’s Republic, think about what you would do if you found a ring like the one the shepherd in the story found. The more honest everyone is, the more interesting this discussion will be. No judging, just thinking and discussing!

In the course of the week’s discussion, you will need to do the following (not necessarily in this order):

Reflect on yourself:
What are you are willing to do with the ring but unwilling to do without it due to fear of negative consequences?
Why are you willing to do this? Try to explain your reasoning as concretely as possible.
Note: you are not being asked to describe what you would do if you had any power you wished. The ring in this story gives its wearer a specific power, and you are asked what you would do with that particular power.
Reflect on society:
Would most people in our society consider your use of the ring to be ethical or unethical? Why?
If you think that your use of the ring would be considered unethical by most people, why would you do it anyway? What does that say about the importance of “ethics”?
If you think that your use of the ring would be considered ethical by most people, explain why you would not act in this way without the ring.
Engage with the text:
Based on what you said in response to the first two questions, does your response agree or disagree with Glaukon’s claims about ethics?
You will need to discuss your interpretation of Glaukon’s claims in responding to this question.
Discuss with your peers:
Read the posts of your peers and discuss their response to these questions. Consider, especially, whether or not you agree with their interpretation of Glaukon and what challenges this discussion raises about ethics.
Remember that how you choose to address these questions is up to you; there’s no required procedure (for instance, you don’t have to answer each in a separate post or anything like that). The main thing is to get thinking and talking about these questions, and I look forward to reading your responses.

You must answer all the questions in the prompt and show evidence of having read the resources that are required to complete the discussion properly (such as by using quotes, referring to specific points made in the text, etc.).